Skip to main content

Mismanagement of Alberta's Oil



Much has been said about the need to support the Oil industry but few have held the industry and Alberta government to account for the the current situation. The current economic plight of Alberta is in part a function of Alberta's own shortsighted conservative mindset.

Let me elaborate.  This is not Alberta's first bear market, and it will not be the last.  So why was there no preparation for another bust given the history of boom and bust? What made Alberta believe they could build a pipeline on someone else's land when they would have fought with equal vigor had their land been earmarked for conservation vs drilling? What made Alberta believe it did not have to save for a rainy day?  What rational resulted in betting the house on being an exporter of a commodity versus investing to make Alberta a value-added player?  It is time Albertans and the media ask these questions of the conservative government that has ruled the province.

During the boom times, there are multiple things Alberta could have done, but did not.  They could have...
  1. Behaved like the socialist Norwegians and establish an Oil Fund to invest royalties of the petroleum sector
  2. Implement a Provincial Sales Tax and store the money for a rainy day
  3. Invest in value added products
  4. Invested in clean energy, the knowledge economy
  5. Invested in the indigenous communities of Canada before they needed them
Instead, the government chose lower taxes, leaving the money in the hands of trickle down economics that left future investment in the hands of those who were a defacto better steward and investor of capital for Albertans.  Clearly this strategy has not worked.



Oil is not going away, nor is Canada's support for the West, but the West needs to act responsibly and cannot creditably ask for government help like a socialist would while decrying government interference as a conservative capitalist would.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

World Quran Recitation List

 Stay tuned, we are crowd sourcing a list of Quran recitations from around the world.   Please contribute here: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSciC5ty7vtUEdA4UPNFlrwdYWGElhDBGUSm8zN7UQ-Ason49Q/viewform?usp=sf_link The list will be shared starting Ramadan 2022 and each Jumah through the month.
Post a Comment
Read more

Student Loans, a % of earnings in a risk sharing agreement

The article below speaks to how some US Universities are extending to students a risk sharing loan program as an alternative to interest bearing student loans. The structure is Islamic, more so than many of the "sharia compliant bonds".  The concept is a pure risk sharing model and a great foundation for a true Islamic loan.  "Fair" is paramount in Islamic finance, so expect a degree of variance in loan programs as some unscrupulous lender looks to take advantage of a students. As a community, would not a fund developed to finance student fees based on a similar model be beneficial to our local Umahs? Source:  https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/businessweek/u-s-college-grads-sell-stakes-in-themselves-to-wall-street-1.1241543 U.S. college grads sell stakes in themselves to Wall Street Claire Boston ,  Bloomberg News Amy Wroblewski , Maura Friedman for Bloomberg Businessweek (Bloomberg Businessweek) -...
Post a Comment
Read more

Introducing Our Model Portfolio | 2-year performance betters 5-year MSCI World Islamic Index

I have built a model portfolio for the last 6 years that has produced a 25+% CAGR. The iShares MSCI World Islamic UCITS ETF has returned -9.37% in 2018 vs our +9.1% for a difference of +18.47% in 2018.  Over a longer period, 5 years, MSCI produced only a cumulative return of 26.38%.  Meaning if you invested $100 at the end of 5 years you would have had $126.38.  In all 2 year periods except one the model portfolio has outperformed the 5-year return of  iShares MSCI World Islamic UCITS ETF - in 2-year our model portfolio has made more than the ETF has in 5-years ! (source:  https://www.ishares.com/uk/professional/en/products/251394/ishares-msci-world-islamic-ucits-etf?switchLocale=y&siteEntryPassthrough=true  ) Some highlights that are noteworthy 1. The lack of correlation to the market, meaning the portfolio does not move in step with the market. 2. The securities purchased that account for 80% of the portfolio are large businesses.  They pro...
Post a Comment
Read more